Wednesday, April 4, 2012
13. Brothers in Arms &...
Lyrics
These mist covered mountains
Are a home now for me
But my home is the lowlands
And always will be
Some day you'll return to
Your valleys and your farms
And you'll no longer burn
To be brothers in arms
Through these fields of destruction
Baptisms of fire
I've witnessed your suffering
As the battles raged higher
And though they hurt me so bad
In the fear and alarm
You did not desert me
My brothers in arms
There's so many different words
So many different songs
We have just one world
But we live in different ones
Now the sun's gone to hill
And the moon's riding high
Let me bid you farewell
Every man has to die
But it's written in the starlight
And every line on your palm
We're fools to make war
On our brothers in arms
The Dire Straits are awesome. This isn't my favorite Dire Straits song, but it still is a powerful anti-war song. It was written as a response to the pointless Falkland War between UK and Argentina in the 1980's. Unfortunately, unlike America and the Vietnam War, the British have hardly made any movies made about this war. The Argentinians have made one major movie about it, Blessed by Fire. Unfortunately I could not find it subtitled. So I had to choose a movie about another war. I chose World War I. That is not a very random choice. Lyrically this song is reminiscent of poems written during World War I by British poets. I don't know much about poetry, but in high school during English classes we once discussed British poetry during World War I. I unfortunately haven't remembered much of it, but I do remember that these poets focused a lot on the fact that the British were going to fight in places far away from home. And the horrid war-torn landscapes of these places were described very vividly in these poems. One of the most famous of these poems is probably Rupert Brooke's The Soldier. Especially the first lines of it: 'If I should die, think only this of me: That there's some corner of a foreign field that is for ever England.' I think that especially the first part of Brothers in Arms is very reminiscent of these poems. Besides this the phrase brothers in arms is often very much associated with the World War I. Due to the horrible life in the trenches many soldiers saw each other as brothers in arms. And as the war progressed, the cause of it seemed more and more pointless and many soldiers began to see their enemy soldiers as brothers in arms too. They only fought and killed them, because their superiors told them to and because otherwise they would be killed themselves.
The Movie: Paths of Glory (Stanley Kubrick, 1957)
As you may have guessed from the former paragraph, one of my favorite subjects during my History classes was World War I. I still do know a lot about it. This may be why I found Paths of Glory to be the most disappointing Kubrick film I've seen. It's by no means a bad film, but it's not really great either. Kubrick is not much interested in creating an interesting story or making us care about the characters. He uses the plot and the characters only to make a point about (the) war. I don't think this is wrong. In fact I actually think that using your characters and plot to say something about something, as opposed to simply tell a story about the lives of these characters that will make us care about them, is the most interesting way to use them. I would argue that this is exactly what Tarantino does in Inglourious Basterds, which may be my favorite film. The problem is that what Kubrick has to say about the war here doesn't really go much further then what we've learned in high school. More importantly, he doesn't say it in a really interesting way. Before I started to watch I was surprised that the movie was only 88 minutes long. After I watched it I thought it could have been way shorter.
IMDB gives the following plot summary of the movie: 'When soldiers in WW1 refuse to continue with an impossible attack, their superiors decide to make an example of them.' This simple sentence is actually the perfect summary of what happens in the movie. Though it's important to note that there is one superior who does defend the soldiers. This is the hero of the movie, Colonel Dax, played by Kirk Douglas. Kubrick uses the plot to say two major things about the war. First of all, Kubrick claims that everything about the war was justified by invoking (often false) feelings of patriotism and nationalism. When for example the soldiers are tried in a 'court' for cowardice their superiors claim that they have to be found guilty, because they are a shame to France. They neglected to fight for their country and thus let their nation and their people down. This is how every country that fought in the war justified its fighting in it. They had to participate in it, because they had to show that they were a great and prideful nation, that was better and greater than other nations. Thus if you refused to fight for your nation, you undermined it and were a disgrace to it. In the final and best scene of the movie Kubrick shows how stupid this line of thinking was (and still is). A bunch of French soldiers have come together to rest a bit in a tavern, when a captured German female singer is brought to entertain them. First she is made fun off and called all kinds of derisive things. But when she starts singing some German song she moves the soldiers to tears and they start humming along to it. The scene shows that the differences between nations are so marginal and unimportant that they can easily be transcended. This of course makes the war incredibly futile and meaningless. And not only do we realize this, so do the soldiers in the tavern, which makes the scene even more sad.
Secondly Kubrick makes the claim that there was a huge dissonance between the soldiers and their superiors. While the soldiers were send on all kinds of dangerous and irresponsible missions, the arrogant superiors hardly experienced the dangers of the war. They could live with losing 55% of their soldiers if the mission succeeded. And while the superiors sold the idea of fighting for France's pride, they themselves hardly cared about France. The main reason for their desire to win a battle was that their status would increase if they won it. Kubrick also makes this dissonance clear with his depiction of the living and 'working' conditions of the soldiers and their superiors. We see the generals and colonels in beautiful, lavish palaces, eating fine foods and attending gallant dances. On the other hand there are the soldiers who live miserably in the trenches. In a long take we follow a general walking through the trenches, inspecting his troops (the only time we actually see a general there) and see all the misery and destruction there.
Lastly some minor notes. While I didn't find the movie that special, it certainly had an impact when it came out. Because of its depiction of the French army, it was forbidden in France until 1975. Germany and Spain also forbade it for some time. The first one because it didn't want to strain its relationship with France. The second one because Franco objected to the anti-militarism in it.
It is astonishing how much Kirk Douglas looks like his son Michael. Before you say d'oh, I understand that fathers and sons are supposed to look like one another, but if you were to make an exact remake of this film with only Michael Douglas, instead of his father, it would be hard to notice.
I once read an interesting observation that it is really hard to make a satisfying movie with a happy ending about World War I. After all most of the characters would be screwed again 20 years later during World War 2. If not earlier. The interbellum was not a very happy period either.
Friday, March 23, 2012
12. Wish You Were Here &..
Lyrics
Heaven from Hell,
Blue sky's from pain.
Can you tell a green field
From a cold steel rail?
A smile from a veil?
Do you think you can tell?
And did they get you to trade
Your heroes for ghosts?
Hot ashes for trees?
Hot air for a cool breeze?
Cold comfort for change?
And did you exchange
A walk on part in the war
For a lead role in a cage?
How I wish, how I wish you were here.
We're just two lost souls
Swimming in a fish bowl,
Year after year,
Running over the same old ground.
And how we found
The same old fears.
Wish you were here.
Out of all the great classic rock groups Pink Floyd is perhaps the most unique one. More then perhaps any other famous band they tried to experiment with their songs and do things nobody else really did. Pink Floyd is also one of the few bands I think who were more interested in rock as a form of art then as a form of entertainment. This is all very admirable, but I am not really a fan of their music. Their songs don't really connect with me. I do like Wish You Were Here a bit more then their other songs though. It's about Syd Barrett, a founding member of Pink Floyd who was their lead vocalist and songwriter. Unfortunately he had to leave them because of a combination of drug abuse and mental illness. I didn't want to choose a movie dealing with madness again though. But I think that without any background knowledge the song can also be interpreted to be about someone returning from war and having trouble to adjust to normal life again. So I chose a classic movie about men returning home from the World War II. Admittedly this is not the greatest link between a song and movie, but it was a very good movie and I don't know when I would have seen it otherwise.
The Movie: The Best Years of Our Lives (William Wyler, 1946)
This is a very good movie that caught me by surprise. I knew that it was a classic movie about three men returning home after fighting in World War 2. I expected that it would be an incredibly dramatic film in which the returned soldiers would have to overcome enormous psychological problems and other such stuff. I expected it also to be sometimes insufferably patriotic and full of heightened melodrama. None of this is true. The movie is very down to earth, feels incredibly modern, and even finds room for some comic relief and light romance. It is also often very realistic. The scenes where the three soldiers return home to see their family again after such a long time could not be better handled and executed. They get everything right. The anxiety you have when you'll see someone again you haven't seen in a long time, the relief and happiness when you see that person again, the blissful first day(s) when you and your old friends and family come together and are just happy to be together without worrying about what will come next, and the end of the blissful days when you have to start living normal life again.
The three soldiers to return are Fred Derry, Al Stephenson and Homer Parrish. Al returns to his wife of 20 years and their children. He needs some time to get used to his wife and children (who he finds have grown considerably, both physically and mentally). Fred can't get a good job after returning from the war. This is the cause of tensions between him and his demanding wife, whom he married just 20 days before the war. On top of this he falls in love with Peggy, Al's daughter. Homers story is the saddest. He has lost both his arms in the war, but his problems are psychological. He can control the mechanic hooks he got in the place of his arms very well. He is mostly afraid of the reactions of his loved ones, including his girlfriend Wilma. He pushes her away because he is convinced she wouldn't want to marry him now. This story has some added poignancy, because Homer is played by Harold Russell, an untrained actor who really lost his arms in the war. It's not much of a surprise that in the end everything will end happily for everyone involved. Yet the movie is never boring. Mostly because these are some of the most convincingly real and pleasant characters I've ever seen in a Hollywood movie. That's quite an achievement for a movie from 1946.
The role of the women in this movie is pretty interesting. During the war the men were fighting abroad so the women at home had to keep the country running. Many of them had to do jobs usually reserved for men. They did this quite successfully and this made them feel more independent. This is reflected in the movie. The women are on the same level as, and sometimes even above, the men. They have their own ideas, they can take care of the family, they are quite simply empowered. It's noticeable for example that not only does Peggy drive a car, but she is behind the wheel even with a man in the car. In fact I don't remember ever seeing a woman being driven by a man in this film. And when the tensions between Fred and his wife become too much, it is her who demands a divorce. The women in this movie are more empowered then they are in many modern movies.
In the IMDB trivia section on this movie I read that the director absolutely hated the score composed for the movie. Well, he was right, it is absolutely horrible. It is incredibly bombastic, and it never fits in the movie. It feels as if it is composed for some completely different movie. On top of this it isn't even pretty to listen to it. This is pretty annoying and can sometimes pull you right out of the movie. Still, that should not stop anyone from watching this movie. It is really very good.
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
11. Clocks &..
Lyrics
The lights go out and I can't be saved
Tides that I tried to swim against
Have brought me down upon my knees
Oh I beg, I beg and plead, singing
Come out of the things unsaid
Shoot an apple off my head and a
Trouble that can't be named
A tiger's waiting to be tamed, singing
You are, you are
Confusion that never stops
The closing walls and the ticking clocks gonna
Come back and take you home
I could not stop, that you now know, singing
Come out upon my seas
Cursed missed opportunities am I
A part of the cure
Or am I part of the disease, singing
You are, you are
You are, you are
You are, you are
And nothing else compares
And nothing else compares
And nothing else compares
You are, you are
Home, home, where I wanted to go
Home, home, where I wanted to go
Home, home, where I wanted to go (You are)
Home, home, where I wanted to go (You are)
Clocks is a fairly enjoyable song, just like most other songs by Coldplay. I am a bit surprised how this song is so high and even more surprised why Coldplay is considered to be a great band. I don't really see what's so special about any of their songs. Lyrically, this is a very vague song, and I had no idea how to make a really logical link between the song and a movie. The clip doesn't help either. All we see is Coldplay performing. But I remembered seeing a clip once from a movie by Roman Polanski in which the walls were closing in on Catherine Deneuve. Besides, I thought, it looks like a movie that might be just as vague as the song So I chose that film. While the movie isn't vague it turned out to be a better fit then I expected. It is about madness and it can be argued that the song also is about someone going, at least slightly, mad.
The Movie: Repulsion (Roman Polanski, 1965)
After The Shining this is already the second movie I discuss that deals with the subject of madness. And in both movies the characters going mad are stuck in a confined space. In The Shining it was a hotel, here it is the apartment of Carole's (Catherine Deneuve) sister. I think that The Shining is a much better and more entertaining film with more virtuoso film making. But it is Repulsion that gives, I believe, a more realistic and more terrifying representation of madness. While in The Shining there was a supernatural reason for Jack to lose his mind, there is nothing supernatural in Repulsion. Carole lives among ordinary people with ordinary jobs who worry about ordinary things. There is no reason for her madness. She is losing her mind, simply because sometimes that happens to some people. At the end of the movie a hint is given for her madness, but it is still a pretty ambiguous hint.
It is clear from the start that Carole is not completely sane. She is repulsed by men and sex. She is kind of dating someone, but she hardly ever shows up to their appointments and is disgusted and unresponsive when he tries to kiss her. She always seems unsure of herself and completely insecure. Many European directors in the 1960's seemed to love to film scenes of women walking through the city, set to jazz/rock music. Polanski does that here too, but these scenes are not pointless. They serve to show how utterly terrified Carole is of the society around her. At the beginning she is still at least functional though. She has a job as a manicure in a beauty salon and has some sort of relationship with her colleagues and her sister with whom she lives. But when her sister leaves on a holiday with her boyfriend, Carole has to stay alone in the apartment and that's when she completely loses it. One can imagine that Carole is not an easy character to play. She doesn't have much dialogue and a lot of the time she is alone. Deneuve does a great job though.
Polanski manages to create suspense and terror by doing very simple things. In the first half of the movie we get a very clear sense of the geography of the apartment. We know how big each room is and how to get to each room. In the second half Polanski simply distorts the space in the apartment. Sometimes he films in such a way that rooms and halls seem larger then they are, and sometimes smaller. But even more impressive is his use of sound. While I have never gone insane, I have obviously been home alone. And when you are home alone you are more aware of sounds around you. A surprising sound can startle even a mentally stable person. The most scary sequence in this film is a short one in which practically nothing happens. Carole has heard a sound which has scared her and now she sits still in bed waiting to hear it again. We don't hear anything either, just wait for something to happen while Carole becomes more and more terrified and eventually hallucinates. I also don't remember seeing a film in which you heard so often the ringing of the telephone or the doorbell. For Carole this sound is extra terrifying. Not just because it is so startling and unexpected, but because it is an intrusion in her personal space. The ringing of a doorbell or a telephone means that a person wants to see you or talk to you. For Carole this has become a terrifying thought. She kills the two people to enter her apartment.
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
10. One &..
Lyrics
Is it getting better
Or do you feel the same
Will it make it easier on you now
You got someone to blame
You say...
One love
One life
When it's one need
In the night
One love
We get to share it
Leaves you baby if you
Don't care for it
Did I disappoint you
Or leave a bad taste in your mouth
You act like you never had love
And you want me to go without
Well it's...
Too late
Tonight
To drag the past out into the light
We're one, but we're not the same
We get to
Carry each other
Carry each other
One...
Have you come here for forgiveness
Have you come to raise the dead
Have you come here to play Jesus
To the lepers in your head
Did I ask too much
More than a lot
You gave me nothing
Now it's all I got
We're one
But we're not the same
Well we
Hurt each other
Then we do it again
You say
Love is a temple
Love a higher law
Love is a temple
Love the higher law
You ask me to enter
But then you make me crawl
And I can't be holding on
To what you got
When all you got is hurt
One love
One blood
One life
You got to do what you should
One life
With each other
Sisters
Brothers
One life
But we're not the same
We get to
Carry each other
Carry each other
One...life
One
This is a great song. I am not really a fan of U2 though. I like some of there songs, but they have also made a lot of songs that I don't find really interesting. But no matter what you think of their songs, it cannot be avoided that U2 currently is the biggest and more important band in the world. There is currently no other band that has such a big impact on popular culture and that so consistently fills stadiums and influences other artists. And while Bono seems a bit of a jerk, he currently is the biggest rock icon. In fact I would say that in rock/pop music history there are four bands that stand above all the rest when it comes to longevity, importance and influence. These are The Rolling Stones, The Beatles, Queen and U2. They have been of great importance to a great many people and no matter what we think of their songs (I am no big fan of the Beatles either), these are the greatest bands of all time.
The song seems to be about a man trying to make amends with a close family member with whom he had a rather horrible past. This close family member is most probably a father. This is supported by the clip; the old man we see is apparently Bono's father with whom Bono used to have a bad relationship, until they reconciled sometime around the making of the song. Though it can also easily be interpreted that the close family member is a brother.
There are obviously a lot of movies about people who try to make amends with some family member with whom they shared a rather unpleasant past. The movie I chose is a new one that is neither the best film about strained family relationships, nor is that really it's most important subject. But I was very pleasantly surprised by it and wanted to write about it.
The Movie: Warrior (Gavin O'Connor, 2011)
Like all sports movies Warrior is rather predictable. After about 15 minutes we have a pretty pretty good idea of what will happen and indeed everything we thought would happen,eventually does happen. But the movie is so well made and has such wonderful characters that its predictability doesn't really matter. It is one of the best sports movies I've seen.
Warrior follows Tommy and Brendan Conlon. They are brothers, who became estranged from each other after Tommy and their mother left Brendan and their alcoholic, abusive father. Brendan didn't stay because of his father though, but because he fell in love with a girl that is now his wife. And now both he and Tommy are estranged from their father and their mother has passed away a long time ago. The scene where Tommy and Brendan confront each other about why one left and the another one stayed is the only scene in the movie with dumb cliche dialogue. But the look and cinematography of that scene is simply wonderful. Besides being brothers Brendan and Tommy are both MMA fighters who decide to fight in the biggest MMA tournament in the USA, both without knowing that the other brother will participate too. It's a winner takes all tournament with the prize money being 5 million dollars. You can guess which two fighters will be in the final.
On the road to the tournament we follow Tommy and Brendan independently from each other. The plot involving Tommy is nothing really special, but it is handled well. To train for the tournament Tommy returns to his father who was his trainer when he was young. Tommy makes clear to his father that their relationship only extends to training together. He doesn't want any reconciliation or anything. This does hurt his father who is recovering from his alcoholism and is on the brink of being alcohol free for 1000 days. Tommy's reasons for fighting in the tournament aren't clear from the start and the movie does a good job of keeping us curious about them. But it's the plot involving Brendan that's really great. In most movies about sports, especially those about sports involving fighting, the heroes aren't really interesting or intelligent people. As Rocky says himself, he is a bum. Brendan is a physics teacher who when he enters the ring is accompanied by music from Beethoven. He is an intelligent man loved by his students. (Though the movie itself doesn't know much about physics. There is no way in one lesson you would learn about Newton's laws and in the very next one about the law of conservation of energy.) He is retired from UFC fighting, but due to financial problems he decides to participate in the tournament. His wife isn't happy about this. After his last fight left him unconscious she made him promise that he would never fight again. In most movies there now would be a huge fight between husband and wife and the wife would threaten to leave the husband with her kids. Just to make a glorious return by the end. Not here. Brendan and his wife discuss his decision very normally. Both make good arguments. In the end his wife supports his decision, without necessarily being happy about it. And the movie never judges her for the fact that she finds it idiotic that her husband will go back to fight. The relationship between Brendan and his trainer is also presented wonderfully. Besides training together they are also just good friends. This friendship is represented very warmly and realistically in the film. These are both good people who want the best for each other and who respect their opponents.
In almost all American sports movies the hero is a huge underdog whose victory or near victory is presented as some sort of victory for the American norms and values. Not here. The movie doesn't pretend that the tournament is anything else but a great opportunity to see some great fighting. There is a big Russian, who has never fought in the USA before, but he is not presented as a villain. In fact he has a lot of fans who just find him awesome and would love to see him win and fight. When Brendan beats his brother, that's great for him. He'll now have 5 million dollars. But it is not presented as some kind of victory for some great American ideal. The audience in the tournament cheers for him after the match, mostly because they just saw an awesome match. Besides, Tommy and Brendan aren't even enormous underdogs. In one of the first scenes it is established that Tommy is incredibly strong when he beats up the world middleweight champion and in the tournament he goes very easily through the first rounds and while the movie doesn't say so, he would probably be considered the favorite to win the tournament after those rounds. Brendan may have been retired from fighting, but he is not a nobody. He was a UFC fighter and there is no reason why he couldn't win the tournament.
Lastly some other notes. The movie understands very well how the media in the 21st century works. When Tommy beats up the middleweight champion in the beginning we someone filming this with his mobile phone. This goes viral on YouTube and creates a hype for Tommy. And there also other examples which show that the movie knows that the internet has become of huge importance for the coverage of sports and news. I don't think that there is another sports movie which gives such a realistic depiction of sports coverage.
I am not a fan of fighting sports and in fact I sometimes have some unfair prejudices against both the participants and the spectators of such sports. But if you are going to watch two people fighting, it doesn't get more exciting then MMA fighting.
Nick Nolte, who plays the father, got an Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor. He is very good in it, but the whole cast is great, especially Joel Edgerton as Brendan.
Friday, February 17, 2012
9. November Rain &...
Lyrics
When I look into your eyes
I can see a love restrained
But darlin' when I hold you
Don't you know I feel the same
'Cause nothin' lasts forever
And we both know hearts can change
And it's hard to hold a candle
In the cold November rain
We've been through this such a long long time
Just tryin' to kill the pain
But lovers always come and lovers always go
An no one's really sure who's lettin' go today
Walking away
If we could take the time
To lay it on the line
I could rest my head
Just knowin' that you were mine
All mine
So if you want to love me
Then darlin' don't refrain
Or I'll just end up walkin'
In the cold November rain
Do you need some time...on your own
Do you need some time...all alone
Everybody needs some time...
On their own
Don't you know you need some time...all alone
I know it's hard to keep an open heart
When even friends seem out to harm you
But if you could heal a broken heart
Wouldn't time be out to charm you
Sometimes I need some time...on my
Own
Sometimes I need some time...all alone
Everybody needs some time...
On their own
Don't you know you need some time...all alone
And when your fears subside
And shadows still remain
I know that you can love me
When there's no one left to blame
So never mind the darkness
We still can find a way
'Cause nothin' lasts forever
Even cold November rain
Don't ya think that you need somebody
Don't ya think that you need someone
Everybody needs somebody
You're not the only one
You're not the only one
I am not really a fan of Guns N' Roses. It's impossible to say that they are a bad band, but except for Sweet Child of Mine there is not a Guns N' Roses song that I really like. November Rain is widely considered to be a classic rock song in the vein of Stairway to Heaven and Hotel California. Unfortunately, to me, the only thing in common between November Rain and the aforementioned songs is that they are long. Quality-wise a song like Stairway to Heaven is incomparable to November Rain. Up until the last two minutes I find November Rain even to be a pretty dull, annoying song. While Slash's solo's (especially his last one) are pretty fantastic, I find Axl Rose's voice a bit annoying. Still even if I don't really like the song, the Roses should be applauded for making it. Even when it was released in 1992, the days of the long ambitious rock songs were pretty much over and since November Rain no new rock band has even tried to do something similar. Therefore it doesn't really deserve that the corresponding movie is so bad. But, even while I knew its pretty horrible reputation, it was the only movie I could really think of. The lyrics of the song actually fit it really well.
The Movie: Sweet November (Pat O'Connor, 2001)
I had never seen Sweet November before, but I knew it as movie with a very bad reputation. After seeing it I can say that its reputation is fully earned. It is rather horrible. It is a remake of a movie from 1968, by the same name. First I thought to watch that movie, because I thought it might be a better one, but that version is incredibly hard to find. Besides, both movies are rated similarly on IMDB and the premise of both movies is so stupid (A dying woman lures emotionally crippled men into one month affairs, and tries to help them repair their lives) that it's hard to make a good movie out of it. And I thought I might enjoy the 2001 version more since Keanu Reeves and Charlize Theron are both actors I like. And they did save the movie from being completely crap, but it is still horrible.
Keanu Reeves is often ridiculed, but I do like him. He is at his best when he plays lighthearted,naive romantics, as in 1989's Parenthood for example. Yet he was also convincing in three of the best action movies of the 90's (Speed, The Matrix and Point Break). What he shouldn't play though is an arrogant asshole. And during the first half of the movie that is exactly what he is supposed to play. He does that with some of the most horrible acting I have ever seen. To be fair though the movie doesn't go easy on him. At one point he has to talk to a sausage.
While the movie portrays Keanu Reeves as an asshole at least it acknowledges that he is an asshole. On the other hand Charlize Theron's behavior in the first half of this movie is that of an insane bitch, but the movie seems to think she is a wonderful person. The movie manages to make us hate a dying woman. That's something few movies can achieve, even intentionally. All of this makes the affair between Theron and Reeves incredibly unbelievable. It's hard to believe that Reeves would fall for Theron. And it's hard to believe that Theron would pursue Reeves so relentlessly. Considering she is dying and has little time left you would think that she would go after someone nicer and someone who can be more easily pursued then Reeves, who rejects her about four times before finally succumbing to her 'charms'.
When they finally start their affair the movie becomes slightly less bad for awhile. The behavior of the characters normalizes, which makes their previous behavior even more bizarre. The movie now follows all of the old romantic cliches and Theron and Reeves try to make the most of it and manage to bring some charm to the whole thing. It's hard not to enjoy a smiling half-naked Charlize Theron, no matter how bad the movie is. Then Reeves finds out Theron is dying and the movie becomes very bad again.
Besides telling a love story, the movie also tried to make some kind of anti-materialistic point. It wants to claim that pursuing love and good relationships with people is much more important than pursuing money. In any scene shot in the financial district of the city the characters are enclosed by buildings and chaos. There is no human contact and everybody minds their own business. On the other hand In the suburbs, where Theron lives there is a lot of open space. There is serenity and a sense of community. People know each other and talk to each other. Charlize Theron mentions that she once had a company where she was doing something with pets, but the company became too big, the human touch was lost and she left it. Anyway, the movie forgets all this in a very stupid scene near the end.
Theron has pushed Reeves away, so he wouldn't have to be bothered with her during her final days. This hurts him a lot and he wants to win her back. So during Thanksgiving he climbs into her apartment dressed as Santa Claus (so she would experience one last Christmas) and brings her twelve gifts. He lists every single gift and in the end literally says: "if these final gift does not show you my love for you, then nothing will." In most romantic comedys/dramas such a scene would be at the beginning to establish that the current lover of our hero(ine) is a jerk.
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Volkertafel
The painting I discuss can be seen here: http://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkertafel
Volkertafel, Nations and Orientalism
One of the most interesting comic book characters is Snowbird. She is a Canadian superhero who can assume the form of any animal that can be found in Canada. But when she crosses the Canadian border she loses all her powers and falls ill (Woo, 76). This implies that there is some sort of natural law, which defines where a nation begins and ends. The case of Snowbird is a great example of how in our current (popular) culture and society the uniqueness of nations and the fact that there are borders between different nations is seen as something completely natural. These ideas about nations are now a completely normal part of our daily lives. When we open an atlas for example we find it pretty normal that every nation has a different color and that there are borders drawn between each nation.
The nations as we know them today, though, are not some natural phenomenon, but they are socially constructed and relatively new. The ideas that each nation is unique, that there are significant differences between the nations and that therefore each nation should have its own state really arose in the 18th century. As Joep Leerssen has stated in his book National Thought in Europe: "We have come to think of nation-states as an ideal systematic taxonomy of Europe where the French live in France and speak the French language, and the Germans live in Germany and speak the German language and each country has its own French or German cuisine,fashions, national anthem and lifestyle. But this simplystic ideal-type of the nation-state is ultimately the inheritance of the encyclopedic and Enlightenment-anthroplogical systematization of stereotypes, hearsay and cross-cultural caricatures"(Leerssen, 70) One such example of systematization of stereotypes is the 18th-century Austrian painting the Völkertafel (Or in English, The Tableau of Nationalities), one of the first cultural objects to endorse the idea that there are significant differences between the nations, that each nation is unique and that therefore every nation should have its own state. This though is not the only reason why this painting is interesting. It also endorses the idea that the western nations are somehow better,more civilized and more cultured than the eastern nations. This western view of the East or Orient is what, more than 200 years after the Völkertafel, Edward Said criticized in his book Orientalism. In this essay I am going to analyze how in the Völkertafel these ideas about nations, the 'West' and the 'East' are expressed and how they are still relevant today.
While it is not known when exactly this painting has been made it is assumed that it is painted sometime between 1720 and 1730. This was an interesting period in Europan history. In 1715 Louis XIV, to whom the famous words 'L'etat, c'est moi' are attributed, had died. It was the end of an era. The king would no longer be seen as the embodiment of the state. More and more it was argued that the state should be defined by the people who live in it and who share a certain cultural identity. And that the rulers of the state should rule in accordance with the values and needs of its people (Leerssen, 71-74). Of course there have been nationalistic ideas in Europe long before this period. But only now did European nationalism really take flight. The nationalist ideas to emerge in this period would change the European society in an unprecedented way. And they still have a major influence on how we organize our current society (Leerssen, 51).
In the Völkertafel we see 10 different people, who each represent a different nationality. From left to right these are Spain, France, Italy, Germany, England, Sweden, Poland, Hungary, Russia and lastly, as the painting states, either Turkey or Greece. This last part is obviously problematic, and I will discuss it later. The first thing to notice is that all the nationalities are dressed in significantly different clothes. We can also see that the people from an eastern nationality are dressed less seriously and in a more exotic way than those from the west. By representing them with these sophisticated coats and hats, the painting signifies that the western people are dignified, serious and rational. At the same time the eastern nationalities are represented with pyjama-like clothes, skirts and a turban. This signifies them as a bit aloof and irrational. It is also interesting that all the eastern people have beards, or moustaches, while the western people are shaven. This could imply that the eastern people are closer to animals and nature than the western ones. The fact that the painter chose clothes to emphasize the differences between the nations is also interesting. Clothes are a major part in our daily lives. Everyone wears them and one of first things we notice when we meet somebody is his or hers clothing. By showing that the nationalities differ so much in such a normal and basic part of our lives, the painting implies that the differnces between the nations matter a lot and cannot be ignored. Following this we could say that the painting makes the differences between the nations a normal part of our daily lives.
The text is where the painting becomes even more interesting. In the upper left corner it is written that this painting gives 'a short description of the peoples you can find in Europe and their character traits'. Beneath that we see a matrix in which in the first column we see the categories by which the nationalities are to be compared. There all kinds of different categories, like 'ilnesses', 'love-life' and 'intelligence'. Then for each nationality it is written how it relates to each category. For example in the category 'their country' it is said for Italy that it is 'very nice and well looking'. What is said about each country is not always positive though. For example in the category intelligence the Russians 'have none.' By comparing the nations through categories that are normal and unavoidable in our daily lives, like death, intelligence and bad habits, we again see that the painting tries to normalize the differences between the nations. The fact that it is a matrix is also very important in this aspect. To qoute Joep Leerssen again: "The matrix imposes as a form the implicit rule that for each of the characteristics a value must be filled in for each of the nationalities. It would not do to leave any of the squares blank. The comparative system imposes a discipline. Not only does it make it easier to visualize things, it forces one to follow the system in all its steps and elements. Nor would it do to list similar values in different squares. Each of the squares has to say something different. The matrix is a system of differences and that is what it must be. A matrix listing similarities would be, by its own rules, stupid' (Leerssen, 64). When it comes to defining a nation, this is something we still do. A teacher once gave a great example of this. In the Netherlands almost everybody is monogamous. Yet you will not very often read that monogamy is a characteristic that defines the Dutch. Mostly because monogamy is just as common to other western nations. The Netherlands will actually be defined by its windmills, tulips or legal drugs. These things are probably not as important to the Dutch as monogamy, but they are more unique to the Netherlands. This is of course not an example that is unique to The Netherlands. A nation is very often defined by the characteristics in which it differs most from other countries, instead of by the characteristics that are the most common to that country. And the nation is not only defined in this way by other nations, who may not know any better, but also by itself. Benedict Anderson's influential book Imagined Communities could offer an explanation for why this is the case. In his book Anderson states that a nation is an imagined community. What he means by this is that 'it is imagined because the members of even the smallest nation will never know most of their fellow-members, meet them or even hear them, yet in the minds of each lives the image of their communion' (Anderson, 6). It should not be very surprising then that according to Anderson printed literature played a major role in the rise of nationalism (Anderson, 25). Since you cannot know most of the members of our community personally, the best way to feel a bond between you and them is by reading about them in books and poems (or by seeing them in paintings). We identify with the characters in these books and poems, because we see they have the same problems, habits or values as us. In other words we realize that we are really a part of the same community, or nation, as them. But for us to truly love our nation, this is often not considered enough. We also have to believe that our nation is better than the other nations, and that it is unlike any other nation. So in many nationalistic cultural objects the differences between our nation and the other ones are emphasized. And not just any differences, but often specifically those that make our nation unique and better. For example the influential German nationalistic poet Ernst Arndt, tried to create a German identity through his poems and filled them with anti-French and antisemitic sentiments (Leerssen, 108). Lastly, in this aspect, it is interesting that while the Völkertafel is an Austrian painting, the Austrians are not represented in it. Thus the painter is not interested at all in giving a representation of his own nation. He is just interested in showing how it differs from other nations. After seeing this painting we do not know what an Austrian is. But we certainly do know what is not an Austrian.
Just like the image of the clothes of the nationalities, the text also shows that the painting has a worldview in which the 'West' is better and more civilized than the 'East' or Orient. We saw the painting supports and propagates the idea that there are differences between the nations. Yet it claims that there are no differences between the Turks and Greeks. This may be because the painter thinks that the two nations are basically the same and do not really have their own identity. Following the philosophy of the painting this makes them inferior to the other nations. There is another possible reason for the painter's claim that there are no differences between the Turks and Greek. It could be that he did not want to waste time exploring the differences between them, since they are nations that are not worthy of much attention. The painting views them as pretty awful. According to it they are lazy, stupid, narcissistic liars who dress like women. It is notable that in the current financial crisis a lot of these adjectivs are often used to describe Greece. And they are only used as a matter of jokes, but also in serious articles and proposals about how to tackle the crisis (van der Ziel,7). Another time when this painting claims that an eastern nation has no identity of its own is when in the category 'national character' is that the Russian national characater is 'very Hungarian.' This obviously is a negative thing by itself. But to make matters worse the Hungarian national character is considered to be 'the cruelest of all.' And in most cases the traits assigned to western nationalities are much more positive than those assigned to eastern ones. In fact the painting is exactly the kind of cultural object that Edward Said criticized in his famous book Orientalism. In his book Said claims that the 'West' has created a very negative idea of the 'East' or the Orient that has no real connection to reality. In many western cultural objects the Orient has been represented, among other things as an exotic place with irrational, violent, uncivilized people who give in to their most basic instincts. As opposed to the representation of the 'west' as a civilized place with cultured, peaceful, rational people with great values like democracy. Because of such represntations, Said claims many people in the western world now really believe in these distinctions between the 'West' and the 'East' (Said, 5-8). The connection between this and the nationalistic books and poems diuscussed, earlier is, I believe, not hard to see. The orieantilst cultural objects basically serve the same purpose as the nationalistic ones. Both want to create a community by differentiating it from other communities. In the last case the communities are just on a much bigger scale. With this in mind, Orientalism can become even more dangerous than it now sometimes is. One of the many problems of the current European Union is that most of its inhabitants do not see themselves as European. They mostly see themselves as Dutch, Spanish or French. While we can move freely in the EU the borders between its members still matter to its inhabitants. The member-states do not want to lose sovereignty to the EU and a member-state will often protest if an EU-decision is in the best interest of the EU, but will weaken the member-state. This makes the functioning and the policy-making of the EU much harder (Van Houtum & Struver, 143). It would help the EU a lot if it could create an European identitty and make sure that the inhabitants of Europe identify themselves as Europeans first. Europan history has provided the EU with a blueprint for how to create a common identity. If they follow that blueprint it is not unconceivable that they use the Orient to create a Europan identity in the same way that Arndt used France to create a German identity. This could dangerously heighten the tensions that already exist between the Middle-East and Europe
Throughout this essay I have argued that nations are socially constructed. This is a claim that should not be very surprising or controversial. In fact many of those who were involved in the creating of a nation openly admitted this. As the 18th century Italian politician and novelist Massimo D'Azeglio for example said: "Now that we have made Italy, we need to make the Italians." D'Azeglio took his own advice seriously and proceded to write historical novels in which he glorified and connected the Italian history and the Italian people (Leerssen, 142). Yet, today the claim that a certain nation is socially constructed or invented and not something natural is often seen as an attack on that nation. Many people who claim to love their nation, would be furious if you told them that their nation is socially constructed. A couple of weeks ago for example one of the American republican presidental candidates Newt Gingrich claimed that the Palestinians are an invented people. He said this in order to support Israel. This is a problematic statement, besides the fact that is Orientalist. The Palestinian people are invented, but so are the Israelis, the Americans, the Dutch, etc. And while I am not a fan of nationalism I would argue that the fact that your nation is socially constructed should make your nation more imprtant to you. Because this implies that your nation is build upon certain ideas, norms and values. And that you are part of that nation because you adhere to these norms, ideas and values, and not because, through sheer coincidence, you are born in it or live in it. This unfortunately also makes nations more dangerous, because they can more easily reject individuals this way.
Literature
- Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities. London: Verso, 2006. Print.
- Leerssen, Joep. National Thought in Europe. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 2010. Print
- Said, Edward. Orientalism. Toronto: Pantheon Books, 1978. Print
- Struver, Anke & van Houtum, Henk. "Borders, Strangers, Doors and Bridges." Space and Polity. 25 Aug. 2010. 141-146. Print
- Woo, Benjamin. "Red and White Tights: Representations of National Identity in Canadian Comic Books." Diss. Simon Fraser University , 2006. Print.
- van der Ziel, Arjen. "Bij Grieken is belofte slechts intentie; interview Renee Hirschon, antropologe en Griekenlandkenner
Sunday, January 22, 2012
8. Old and Wise &...
Lyrics
As far as my eyes can see
There are Shadows approaching me
And to those I left behind
I wanted you to Know
You've always shared my deepest thoughts
You follow where I go
And oh when I'm old and wise
Bitter words mean little to me
Autumn Winds will blow right through me
And someday in the mist of time
When they asked me if I knew you
I'd smile and say you were a friend of mine
And the sadness would be Lifted from my eyes
Oh when I'm old and wise
As far as my Eyes can see
There are shadows surrounding me
And to those I leave behind
I want you all to know
You've always Shared my darkest hours
I'll miss you when I go
And oh, when I'm old and wise
Heavy words that tossed and blew me
Like Autumn winds that will blow right through me
And someday in the mist of time
When they ask you if you knew me
Remember that You were a friend of mine
As the final curtain falls before my eyes
Oh when I'm Old and wise
As far as my eyes can see
This is a very moving 'farewell song.' It's most probably about death, although any interpretation involving some sort of farewell makes (at least a little bit of) sense. It's a very famous song, but most people probably would have no idea what the Alan Parsons Project is, if you'd ask them. At least I had heard this song, long before I heard that there was a band called the Alan Parsons Project. It's not a really great name for a band. The movie I've chosen is John Wayne's final movie in which his character is dying of cancer. I thought that Wayne himself was also dying of cancer while making the film, but it turned out that was not the case. He died three years after he played in it. Still, this does add some poignancy to the film.
The Movie: The Shootist (Don Siegel, 1976)
One of the reasons I've started this blog was to urge myself a bit more to watch more diverse movies. There are whole genres and periods from which I have hardly seen any movie. I have hardly seen any movies from before 1970 and I am not very familiar with the great stars from that era. I have not seen Casablanca or Citizen Kane for example. I have hardly seen any movie from the great non-American/English directors. A Bout de Souffle is the only movie from the French New Wave I've seen. I have hardly seen any silents or any really experimental films. And I have hardly seen any true westerns. In fact I can list all four I've seen: John Fords' Stagecoach, Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven, The Coen's True Grit and Sergio Leone's A Fistful of Dollars. And now, The Shootist, which besides being my fifth western, is also only my second John Wayne film (after, obviously, Stagecoach), my second James Stewart film (after Vertigo), my second Lauren Bacall film (after Murder on the Orient Express), and the second film directed by Don Siegel I've seen (after The Invasion of the Body Snatchers). Don't worry, I won't do this again. I just wanted to show that I've seen very few films of these classic directors and stars.
Anyway, I liked The Shootist a lot and it may now be my favorite western. John Wayne may not have known that this was his last film, it is certainly made as it would be his last. Right at the start the movie wants to establish that John Wayne and his character J.B. Books belong to an era that that has either ended or is about to end. The movie introduces Books with black and white clips from John Wayne's old films in which he is young and energetic. But then the movie turns to color and we see the old John Wayne playing the now old Books. Books goes to some town where 15 years ago he was helped by a doctor (James Stewart). He has been diagnosed with cancer and wants a second opinion from the only doctor he trusts. The big news in town is that the British Queen Victoria has just died. It's 1901, the Victorian era and the 19th century has just ended. A new era and a new century is starting. And the town is preparing itself for modern inventions, like electricity and even more importantly cars. There will be no more cowboys on horses.
The doctor confirms that Books has cancer and that he has very little time left. Books wants to spend his last days calmly and die with some dignity and rents a room at Mrs. Rogers hotel. Now the rest of the movie we just see Books preparing for his death. The movie manages to be very entertaining, with quite some humor even, yet it is always respectful of Books and is never going for cheap sentimentality. As hard as he tries, Books just can't live out his final days peacefully. He is notorious and famous as a great shootist who has killed 30 men. Books claims they all had it coming. Mrs. Rogers is not very happy that he is in her hotel, because he scares away her customers. But when she hears he has cancer, she sympathizes with him and even creates some sort of friendship. Her son Gillom is excited that such a celebrity is in their hotel and bugs Books with all kinds of questions and wants Books to give him shooting lessons. Both Marshall Thibido and the local undertaker cannot wait to see Books dead and regularly visit him to see his 'progress.' And a journalist and an old love of Books try to persuade him to let them write and sell his memoirs. As I said this is all done very entertainingly and respectfully. The last sequence is a bit problematic though.
Earlier the doctor told Books that a courageous man such as him should try to avoid dying in the enormous pain that all cancer patients die in. So Books arranges himself a final shootout with three of his former enemies, who, because of their criminal activities, are not the most beloved people in town. This sequence is wonderfully filmed and creates quite some suspense. But, besides the fact that it could be argued that the sequence posits that sometimes killing people is courageous and moral, it also does not make much sense. If after all Books kills his enemies, he won't die himself. Of course he eventually does kill his enemies and is then killed by the barman of the saloon in which the shootout takes place. This is a little bit silly and too coincidental. The barman is in his turn killed by Gillom, who the movie sets up as the new John Wayne. Ron Howard who plays Gillom, would not become the new John Wayne. He would become though the Oscar-winning director of A Beautiful Mind.